Skip to content
AEO for Nonprofits by Dance

Guide · Nonprofit SEO

Nonprofit Website SEO Checklist: What to Fix First

This nonprofit SEO checklist puts the fixes in order, so a staff member or board volunteer can review your website in one afternoon and know what to change first. It covers the facts Google Search and Maps rely on, and the facts AI assistants like ChatGPT and Google AI Overviews need before they will mention your organization. Start at the top. The early items matter most to donors, volunteers and the people you serve.

AEO for Nonprofits · Updated · 9 min read

How to use this nonprofit SEO checklist

Work through the list in order and write down what you find before you fix anything. The order follows impact. A wrong pantry hour or an old address sends a family to a locked door today. A weak page title costs you visibility slowly. Fix what hurts people first.

You need a phone, a laptop, a login to your Google Business Profile if you have one, and about four hours. You do not need to know how to code. A shared document where you list each problem, the page it is on and who can fix it is enough.

Part, What you check, Rough time
PartWhat you checkRough time
1. Contact factsAddress, phone, hours, service times, locations30 minutes
2. Key pagesPrograms, donate, volunteer, get help60 minutes
3. Titles and headingsWhat Google shows in results45 minutes
4. Mobile and accessibilitySpeed, tap targets, readable text30 minutes
5. AI answersWhat ChatGPT and AI Overviews say about you30 minutes
6. ListingsGoogle, Apple, Bing, Candid, Charity Navigator45 minutes

Start here: contact facts, hours and locations

Your basic facts have to be correct, easy to find and the same everywhere. Google and AI assistants compare your site with your listings. When they don't match, the assistant may skip you or give someone the wrong information. For a food pantry, a Sunday service or an adoption event, a wrong hour is the most expensive mistake on this list.

  • Your legal name and the name people actually use both appear on the site, for example "Riverside Community Food Bank (formerly Eastside Pantry)."
  • Street address, phone and a monitored email are in the footer of every page, written as text, not inside an image.
  • Hours are listed for each program, not just the office: pantry distribution, thrift store, museum galleries, shelter adoption hours, worship service times.
  • Holiday and seasonal changes are posted, with the date they were last updated.
  • If you have more than one location, each site has its own section or page with its own address and hours.
  • If you serve people at their homes or across a county, the area is named in plain words ("We deliver meals in Lane and Linn counties").
  • Your EIN and 501(c)(3) status, or church status, appear on the About or Donate page. Ask your accountant or compliance advisor what wording to use about tax-deductibility.

Program, donate and volunteer pages

Each main reason people come to you needs its own page with a clear purpose. A single "What We Do" page that lists eight programs in one paragraph gives Google and AI assistants nothing specific to match to a search like "free tax help for seniors in Dayton" or "youth mentoring volunteer opportunities near me."

Program and get-help pages

  • One page per major program or service: food distribution, after-school tutoring, pet adoption, grief support, field trips.
  • Each page says who it is for, what it costs (or that it is free), eligibility, what to bring, where and when.
  • Each page answers the questions your front desk hears every week, in plain language.
  • A "Get help" or "Find food" link sits in the main menu for people you serve, not hidden under About.

Donate page

  • Your Donate link is visible in the menu on mobile.
  • The page says what a gift does, in concrete terms you can stand behind.
  • Other ways to give are listed: monthly giving, in-kind donations, stock, employer matching, donation drop-off hours.
  • Links to your annual report, Form 990 or Candid profile are close by for donors who check before giving.

Volunteer page

  • Current roles are listed with time commitment, age minimums, background check requirements and location.
  • Group and corporate volunteering has its own section if you offer it.
  • There is one clear next step: a sign-up form, an orientation date or a named contact role.

If volunteers are your biggest gap, our guide on recruiting volunteers through search goes deeper on that page.

Titles, headings and page descriptions

Every page needs a unique title that says what the page is and where you are. Google often uses the title as the blue link in search results, and its SEO Starter Guide recommends titles that are unique, clear and describe the page. Many nonprofit sites still have "Home," "Page 2" or the same title on every page.

Weak title

Programs | Hope Center

Clear title

Free Food Pantry in South Tulsa, Open Tue and Sat | Hope Center

Illustrative example written for this page.
  • Search Google for site:yourdomain.org and scan the titles that appear. Note any duplicates or vague ones.
  • Each page has one main heading (H1) that matches its purpose, such as "Adopt a Dog" or "Volunteer at the Food Bank."
  • Subheadings follow the questions people ask: Who can get food? What should I bring? When are you open?
  • Each important page has a meta description, a one- or two-sentence summary that may appear under the title in results. Lead with the answer.
  • Photos have short alt text describing what they show, such as "Volunteers sorting produce at the Saturday distribution."

Structured data, which is code that restates your page's facts for search engines, is the next step after titles. Our guide on adding schema markup to a nonprofit website explains the NGO and local business types. It helps, but it won't fix a page that lacks the facts in the first place.

Mobile speed and accessibility basics

Test your site on your own phone, on cellular data, the way a parent looking for a pantry or a volunteer checking a shift time would. Many people you serve use a phone as their only internet device. A slow, cramped page loses them before they find the hours.

  • The homepage loads and becomes usable within a few seconds on cellular data.
  • Huge photo sliders and autoplay videos at the top are replaced or compressed.
  • Phone numbers are tap-to-call and addresses open in maps.
  • Buttons are large enough to tap without zooming, and text is readable without pinching.
  • Text has strong contrast against the background. Pale gray on white is hard to read.
  • Key information, such as flyers with event dates, is written on the page and not only posted as a PDF or image.
  • Donation and volunteer forms work on a phone from start to finish. Complete one yourself.
  • Pages that matter work in Spanish or your community's main languages if you serve those communities.

Check your nonprofit in ChatGPT and AI Overviews

Ask AI assistants the questions your community asks, and write down whether you are mentioned and whether the facts are right. This is where AEO (answer engine optimization) starts: making your site clear enough that AI tools can understand it, trust it and recommend you. Google says its AI Overviews and AI Mode rely on the same SEO basics as regular search. You don't need special markup, but your pages do have to be indexable and helpful.

  1. 1

    Ask local questions

    In ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Google, try searches like "food pantries open Saturday near [your town]," "where can I volunteer with animals in [city]," or "churches with Spanish services in [neighborhood]."

  2. 2

    Ask about you by name

    Try "What does [your organization] do?" and "Is [your organization] a legitimate charity?" Check the mission, address, hours and programs in the answer.

  3. 3

    Note the sources

    Where the tool shows its sources, write down which pages it used: your site, Candid, a news story, Yelp or an old directory. Wrong facts usually trace back to one of these.

  4. 4

    Check crawler access

    Ask your web person to open yourdomain.org/robots.txt, the file that tells crawlers which pages they may visit. Make sure it doesn't block Googlebot or OAI-SearchBot, the crawler OpenAI uses to show sites in ChatGPT search.

Example ChatGPT answer (illustrative) · illustrative

Question: Where can I get free groceries on a Saturday in South Tulsa?

Answer: Hope Center runs a free food pantry on S. Peoria Ave, open Saturdays 9 to noon. No ID is required for your first visit. Bring your own bags if you can.

Why it works: the pantry's own page states the day, hours, address and what to bring in plain text, and its Google listing matches.

robots.txt that allows search and ChatGPT search crawlers
User-agent: Googlebot
Allow: /

User-agent: OAI-SearchBot
Allow: /

User-agent: *
Disallow: /wp-admin/

Sitemap: https://www.example.org/sitemap.xml

OpenAI lists GPTBot, its training crawler, separately from OAI-SearchBot. Your organization can decide on each one separately. For more, see how nonprofits show up in ChatGPT.

Listings and profiles to keep consistent

Your name, address, phone, hours and website link should match on every major profile. Google's local ranking help says results depend on relevance, distance and prominence, and that complete, accurate information helps. AI assistants also cross-check these profiles.

Profile, What to check
ProfileWhat to check
Google Business ProfileReal-world name with no added keywords, correct category (food bank, church, animal shelter, museum), hours, holiday hours, photos, website link
Apple Business ConnectApple Maps listing claimed, with matching hours and address
Bing PlacesListing claimed, which also feeds some other services
Candid (GuideStar)Profile current, mission and programs updated, logo and website correct
Charity NavigatorName, EIN and website match. Profile claimed if available to you.
Facebook, Yelp, local directoriesHours and address match. Old locations closed or marked moved.

According to Google's guidelines, the name on your profile should be the same one your organization uses in the real world. Adding words like "Best Dog Rescue Denver" breaks the rules and can get the listing suspended. The full walkthrough is in our nonprofit Google Business Profile guide, and our guide to which nonprofit directories matter covers Candid, Charity Navigator and others.

What to fix first after your afternoon

Sort your notes into three groups and work them in this order.

  1. This week: wrong hours, addresses or phone numbers anywhere; broken donate or volunteer forms; a robots.txt that blocks search crawlers.
  2. This month: separate pages for each program, clear donate and volunteer pages, unique titles and descriptions, matching listings on Google, Apple, Bing and Candid.
  3. This quarter: mobile speed fixes, structured data, a short answer section on each program page, and a monthly AI answer check.

If no one on your staff or board has time for this, AEO for Nonprofits offers a free nonprofit website review. You enter your website address and email, and a person on the team reads the review before it is emailed to you, in plain language, with what to fix first. If it's a fit, the team does the work on your existing site, and nothing goes live until you approve it.

Questions

How long does a nonprofit SEO checklist take to run?

One person can run this checklist in about one afternoon, roughly four hours. Fixing what you find takes longer. Correcting hours and listings takes a day, and building new program pages can take a few weeks.

What is the most important item on a nonprofit website checklist?

Accurate contact facts: address, phone and hours for each program, matching your Google Business Profile. A wrong pantry time or service time sends people to a closed door, and mismatched facts make Google and AI assistants less confident about recommending you.

How do I check if ChatGPT recommends my nonprofit?

Ask ChatGPT the questions your community asks, such as where to find a food pantry or volunteer with animals in your town, then ask about your organization by name. Note whether you appear, whether the facts are right, and which sources it cites. Also confirm your robots.txt file doesn't block OAI-SearchBot.

Do we need a new website to fix our nonprofit SEO?

Usually not. Most problems on this checklist, such as vague titles, missing program pages, wrong hours and slow images, can be fixed on your current site. A rebuild only makes sense if your platform can't be edited or won't work on phones.

Does schema markup guarantee our nonprofit shows up in AI Overviews?

No. Google says AI Overviews use the same basics as regular search, and no special markup is required. Schema helps search engines read your facts, but clear, accurate, helpful pages matter more.

Sources

Get your free nonprofit website review

Enter your website and email, and get a free, personalized review of what is holding your nonprofit back on Google, Google Maps and AI answers like ChatGPT, and what to fix first.

Free and personalized. Just your website and email, no account needed.