Skip to content
AEO for Nonprofits by Dance

Service · Website review

Free Nonprofit Website Review

A free nonprofit website review is a plain-language look at your current site, done by a real person, showing why donors, volunteers and the people you serve may not find you on Google, Google Maps or in AI answers from ChatGPT and Google AI Overviews. You send your website address and email, and you get back a short list of what to fix first. It is not an automated score.

AEO for Nonprofits · Updated · 8 min read

What the free nonprofit website review covers

The review covers three things: your website, the listings that describe your organization elsewhere, and how both show up when someone searches or asks an AI assistant. It works like a nonprofit website audit, but the goal is a short list of what to fix first, not a long report.

You enter two things on the free review form: your website address and your email. That's all. You don't fill out a questionnaire, create an account or book a call. The review gets your mission, programs, location and service area from your site itself. That's on purpose. If a reviewer can't work out what you do and where from your pages, Google and ChatGPT probably can't either.

  • Your website: whether each program, service, worship time, adoption process or distribution site has a clear page that Google can find and read.
  • Your facts: name, address, hours, service area, EIN and contact details, and whether they match across your pages.
  • Your listings: whether your Google Business Profile and major directory profiles agree with your site.
  • Technical basics: page titles, mobile usability, broken links, crawler access and schema markup (code that restates your page's facts for search engines).
  • AI answers: how assistants describe or skip your organization when someone asks about causes, services or volunteering near them.

A real person, not an automated score

A real person reads every review before it reaches you. Automated nonprofit SEO audit tools are good at counting things, like missing alt text or slow images. They can't tell whether a stranger would understand that your food pantry serves three counties, or that your Donate page never says what a gift pays for.

Nonprofits have problems a generic score usually misses. Here are some examples:

  • A church site that lists Sunday service times only inside a PDF bulletin or a Facebook post.
  • An animal rescue whose adoptable pets sit on a third-party widget, so the rescue's own site says almost nothing about adoption fees, the application or the area it serves.
  • A food bank with one generic Get Help page and no list of partner pantry locations, hours or eligibility notes.
  • A museum with admission prices and free days in an image, which search engines and AI assistants read poorly.
  • A foundation site that never says what it funds, where, or how grantseekers apply.

What we check for donors, volunteers and the people you serve

The review checks your site for each group that searches for you, because a donor, a volunteer and someone who needs help each search differently and need different answers.

Who is searching, What they type or ask, What the review checks on your site
Who is searchingWhat they type or askWhat the review checks on your site
Donors"animal rescue to donate to near me", "is [your name] legitimate"A clear mission, what gifts fund, legal name and EIN, a working donate path, and listings that match
Volunteers"volunteer opportunities this weekend", "food bank volunteer [city]"A volunteer page with roles, times, age rules, location and how to sign up, without requiring a PDF
People you serve"food pantry open Saturday", "free tax help near me", "church with Spanish service"Program pages with hours, eligibility, languages, address or service area, and what to bring
Visitors and members"museum free admission day", "church service times"Hours, admission or service times as plain text, parking and accessibility details
Grantseekers and partners"foundation grants for youth programs [state]"Funding priorities, geography, deadlines and how to apply

For an owner or executive director, the useful takeaway is simple: every group you need should be able to find one page that answers its question in the first few lines. Our nonprofit website SEO checklist explains how to check this yourself.

How we look at your presence in ChatGPT and Google AI Overviews

The review checks whether AI assistants can find clear, consistent facts about your organization, because that's what they use when they decide whether to mention you. This work is called AEO (answer engine optimization). It means making your site easy for AI tools to read, trust and quote.

According to Google, AI Overviews and AI Mode depend on the same SEO fundamentals as regular search, and you don't need any special markup to show up in them. ChatGPT search uses OpenAI's crawler, OAI-SearchBot. Your site can block or allow it in a robots.txt file, which tells crawlers what they may visit. So the review checks things you control:

  • Your robots.txt file and site settings don't accidentally block Googlebot or OAI-SearchBot.
  • Your programs, area served and eligibility are written as plain text, not only in images, PDFs or embedded calendars.
  • Your name, address and phone number match on your site, your Google Business Profile and directories such as Candid and Charity Navigator.
  • Your site has proof: annual reports, program results you've published, reviews and press mentions, so an assistant has a reason to trust you.
  • NGO or local organization schema markup is present and matches what's on the page.
Example AI answer (illustrative) · illustrative

Question: Where can I volunteer at a food pantry in Dayton on weekends?

Weak result: The assistant names two larger organizations. Yours isn't mentioned because your site has no volunteer page and your Saturday shifts appear only on Facebook.

Stronger result: The assistant lists your pantry with its Saturday morning shifts, the minimum age and a sign-up link, all taken from a clear volunteer page.

Nobody can guarantee that an AI assistant will mention a particular organization. What you can control is giving it accurate, easy-to-find facts. Read more in how nonprofits show up in ChatGPT.

What you get back by email

You get a plain-language email that explains what's holding your site back and the few things to fix first, in order. It doesn't need a web developer to understand, and it doesn't bury the important points under hundreds of minor warnings.

Example review excerpt (illustrative) · illustrative

1. Your Google Business Profile lists you as open weekdays 9 to 5, but your site says the pantry is open Tuesday and Saturday. Pick one schedule and use it everywhere.

2. Your website has no page for your senior meal delivery program, so people searching for meal delivery for seniors in your county can't find it. One clear page with eligibility and service area would fix this.

3. Your Donate page doesn't say what a gift funds or show your EIN. Donors and AI assistants both look for this.

4. Your robots.txt file blocks all crawlers except Google. Unless you meant to do this, ChatGPT search can't read your site.

Many fixes are things your staff or volunteers can do in an afternoon, such as correcting hours on your Google Business Profile. Others, like adding schema markup to your nonprofit website, take more technical work. The email tells you which is which.

What happens next if it is a fit

If the review shows clear room to improve and you'd like help, the next step is a conversation, not a new website. Everything happens on the site you already have.

  1. 1

    Send your website

    Enter your website address and email. After that, you can book a call with the Dance team if you'd like to talk it through.

  2. 2

    Read your review

    A person reads your review before it's emailed to you. Use it on your own, or ask for help with the fixes.

  3. 3

    Agree on what to improve

    Typical work includes a page for each program or service, clear facts, service-area and location content, technical fixes, schema markup and trust signals such as financial transparency.

  4. 4

    Approve every change

    Nothing goes live on your site or accounts until you approve it. Your board, staff and brand guidelines stay in charge.

  5. 5

    Keep improving monthly

    The work continues month after month. Your site and Google Business Profile are kept consistent with other listings, and new pages answer the questions donors, volunteers and clients actually ask.

For the full process, see how AEO for Nonprofits works.

Why a nonprofit website review is worth doing

People are already looking for nonprofits online, so it's worth knowing whether your site holds up when they find it. Google Ads keyword data for the United States, checked November 2026, shows about 1,900 monthly searches each for "nonprofit website" and "church website", and about 720 for "nonprofit website design". Those are only the searches about websites. Searches for food pantries, adoptable pets, service times and volunteer shifts happen every day in every town.

Many organizations respond by redesigning their site. A redesign can help, but it often moves the same gaps to a new layout: no program pages, hours only in images, listings that don't match. A review first shows whether the problem is the design or the content and facts underneath it. Fixing those is usually faster and cheaper than starting over.

Questions

Is the free nonprofit website review really free?

Yes. You enter your website address and email, and the review is emailed to you at no cost. You don't need to create an account or book a call, and you can use the findings on your own.

What do I need to provide?

Only your website address and your email. The review gets your mission, programs, location and service area from your site. If those are hard to find, that becomes one of the findings.

Will the review tell me why ChatGPT doesn't mention my nonprofit?

It checks the things that affect whether AI assistants can use your site. That includes whether crawlers such as OAI-SearchBot can reach your pages, whether your programs and area served are written as plain text, and whether your facts match your listings. No one can guarantee an AI assistant will mention you, but you can remove the common reasons it skips you.

How is this different from an automated nonprofit SEO audit tool?

Automated tools count technical issues and give you a score. A real person reads this review and looks at what's missing for donors, volunteers and the people you serve, like a missing volunteer page or service times buried in a PDF. You get a short, ordered list of what to fix first instead of a long list of warnings.

Do we need a new website to work with you?

No. The review and any follow-up work focus on the website you already have. If you go ahead, you approve every change before it goes live.

Does this work for churches, museums and animal rescues, not just charities?

Yes. The review looks at whatever your organization offers, such as service times, admission details, adoption processes, food distribution sites or grant guidelines. The questions differ by type of organization, but the checks follow the same idea: clear facts, one page per need, and listings that match.

Sources

Get your free nonprofit website review

Enter your website and email, and get a free, personalized review of what is holding your nonprofit back on Google, Google Maps and AI answers like ChatGPT, and what to fix first.

Free and personalized. Just your website and email, no account needed.