Who to ask: volunteers, donors, guests and adopters
Ask the people who chose to be involved with you and would be comfortable having their name on a public review. For most nonprofits, that means four groups. All of them have a real experience to describe, and none of them has to reveal anything private to write about it.
| Group | What they can speak to | Good moment to ask |
|---|---|---|
| Volunteers | How shifts are organized, how they were trained and welcomed, whether teens or groups can help | Right after a shift, or after their first month |
| Donors | How their gift was thanked and reported, how easy it was to give, what they saw at a site visit | After a thank-you call, tour or impact update |
| Event guests | The gala, 5K, open house, concert or exhibit they attended | The same evening or the next morning |
| Adopters and families | The adoption process, the staff, how the animal settled in | Two to three weeks after adoption |
| Museum visitors and congregants | Exhibits, programs, accessibility, how welcome they felt | After a visit, class or community event |
Reviews that describe something specific do the most good. "Easy to sign up for Saturday sorting shifts at the warehouse" tells the next volunteer far more than "Great place." Animal rescues and shelters have a natural advantage here, because adopters love telling the story. The animal rescue marketing guide covers how to use those stories on your site as well.
Staff, board members and their close family should not review your organization. Google treats reviews from people who work for or run a place as a conflict of interest. Core volunteers who help lead the organization should hold back too. Regular volunteers describing their own shifts are a different case, but confirm with your own advisors if you're unsure.
When not to ask for a review
Don't ask people you serve for a review when it would reveal that they needed help. A Google review is public and usually shows the reviewer's name and photo. If a food pantry client, shelter resident or counseling participant posts one, anyone who searches can see that they used your services.
- Food bank and pantry clients. Many people keep food insecurity private. Never ask at the distribution line, where saying no can feel risky. See food bank SEO for other ways to show your impact.
- Domestic violence, housing and shelter clients. A review can expose where someone is staying. Many confidential shelters shouldn't have a public address on Google at all.
- Recovery, mental health and medical programs. A review can disclose a health condition. If your organization handles health information, check what you can and can't do with your compliance advisor.
- Immigration, legal aid and youth programs. Reviews can expose immigration status, legal matters or minors.
- Anyone in a moment of need. Someone who just received emergency help may feel they have to say yes.
If clients choose to leave reviews on their own, that's their decision. Your job is to stop asking them and to reply in a way that protects them, which is covered below.
How to get reviews for a nonprofit after events and volunteer shifts
The simplest way to get reviews for a nonprofit is a short, personal ask with a direct link, sent within a day of a good experience. Your Google Business Profile can give you a review link that opens the review box directly. Use that link everywhere. Our Google Business Profile guide explains where to find it.
- 1
Get your review link and make a QR code
Copy the short review link from your Business Profile and turn it into a QR code. Put it on the event check-out table, the volunteer sign-in clipboard, adoption folders and exhibit exit signs.
- 2
Add it to emails you already send
Volunteer shift thank-yous, event follow-ups, adoption check-ins and donor impact updates all have room for one line and a link. Don't create a separate campaign if you don't need one.
- 3
Say it out loud once
A volunteer coordinator who says at the end of a shift, "If you had a good time, a Google review helps other volunteers find us," will get more reviews than any email. Make the same ask of everyone, not only the ones who seemed happiest.
- 4
Suggest what to mention, not what to say
Asking people to mention what they did ("the Saturday food sort," "adopting Biscuit") gets useful detail. Never write the review for them or ask for a star rating.
- 5
Ask in batches, steadily
A few reviews every month looks natural and keeps your profile current. A sudden flood after one big push can look unusual.
Subject: Thank you for Saturday's shift
Hi Maria, thank you for helping sort 1,200 pounds of produce on Saturday.
If you have a minute, would you share your experience on Google? Other volunteers read reviews before signing up. Mentioning what the shift was like helps the most.
[Leave a review]
Either way, we hope to see you on the 14th.
Reviews from volunteers also help recruitment, because people who search for "volunteer opportunities near me" read them. The volunteer recruitment through search guide goes further on this.
Google's review rules nonprofits should know
Google's rules come down to this: reviews must be real, unpaid and from people with a real experience, and you can't filter who gets asked based on what they'll say. Breaking them can get reviews removed or put restrictions on your profile. In the United States, the FTC also has its own rule against fake reviews and review suppression.
- No incentives for reviews: no raffle entries, discounts, free admission, tote bags or donation matches in exchange for reviewing. Google prohibits incentives even when you ask for an honest review.
- No review gating: don't send a "How did we do?" survey and then send only happy people to Google.
- No reviews from staff, board members or family (conflict of interest).
- No fake or bought reviews, and no reviews written by an agency or volunteer on someone else's behalf.
- No pressure to remove or change a negative review, and no threats or offers in exchange.
- No reviews of another organization you compete with for grants or donors.
- Don't ask people to review from a shared device at your front desk. Let them use their own phone.
The incentive rule catches nonprofits more than anything else, because raffles and thank-you gifts are normal in fundraising. Keep them separate. You can thank volunteers with a pizza night, but not as a reward for reviews. For rules on regulated programs such as health or legal services, confirm with your compliance advisor.
How reviews influence AI answers
AI assistants use reviews as evidence that an organization is real, active and good at what it says it does. When someone asks ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity or Google's AI Mode "where can I volunteer with animals on weekends near Tulsa" or "which food banks accept donations on Sundays," the answer draws on listings, websites and the language people use in reviews.
Question: Where can my teenager volunteer with dogs on weekends in Tulsa?
Answer: Riverside Animal Rescue runs Saturday dog-walking shifts for volunteers 14 and up with a parent. Reviewers mention a short orientation and friendly coordinators. Their website lists the sign-up steps and the ages they accept.
Notice what that answer needed: a clear fact on the website (ages, days, sign-up steps), a matching listing, and reviews that back it up. Reviews alone don't do it. An assistant also needs:
- A website that states your services, hours, area and how to give or volunteer in plain sentences.
- The same name, address and phone on Google, Apple Maps, Bing and nonprofit directories.
- Recent reviews that mention specific programs, not just star ratings.
- Replies from you that show the organization is active.
No one can guarantee an AI assistant will name you, but these are the parts you control. AEO (answer engine optimization) is the work of making those facts easy for assistants to find and trust. Read more in how nonprofits show up in ChatGPT. On the Google side, Google says reviews and replies to them are part of how local results are ranked. The Google Maps ranking guide explains the rest.
Replying to every review
Reply to every review, good or bad, within a few days, and never confirm private details about the reviewer. Replies show donors and volunteers that someone is paying attention. They also give you a chance to add useful detail, like shift times or how to schedule a tour.
Thanks so much!! We're glad our pantry could help you and your kids get through a hard month.
Thank you for taking the time to write this. Our team works hard to make everyone feel welcome, and we're glad you shared your experience.
The weak reply confirms publicly that the reviewer used the pantry and had a hard month. The better reply is warm without revealing anything. For volunteers, donors and adopters you can be more specific: thank them for the Saturday shift, or ask how Biscuit is settling in.
Handling negative reviews
- Stay calm and brief. Acknowledge the concern, and don't argue in public.
- Offer a direct contact, such as the volunteer coordinator's email, to sort it out offline.
- Never discuss a client's case, eligibility or history in a reply.
- If a review breaks Google's policies (spam, off-topic, hate speech, or from someone who was never involved), report it through your Business Profile instead of replying angrily.
If you'd rather have this handled for you, AEO for Nonprofits starts with a free nonprofit website review: you send your website address and email, and you get a plain-language report on what's holding your site and listings back. Ongoing review and listing work is described on our nonprofit reviews page, and you approve every change before it goes live.
Questions
Can a nonprofit offer a raffle entry or gift for leaving a Google review?
No. Google's policies prohibit offering incentives in exchange for reviews, even if you ask for an honest one. Keep your thank-you gifts and raffles completely separate from any review request.
Should our volunteers and board members leave Google reviews?
Staff, board members and their close family shouldn't review your organization, because Google treats that as a conflict of interest. Regular volunteers describing their own shifts are generally a different case. If someone helps run the organization, it's safest for them not to review it.
Is it okay to ask the people we serve for reviews?
Usually not, if a public review would reveal that they needed help, as with food assistance, shelter, recovery or legal aid. A Google review shows the reviewer's name, so it can expose private circumstances. Ask volunteers, donors, event guests and adopters instead.
Do Google reviews help a nonprofit appear in ChatGPT or AI Overviews?
They can help. AI assistants use reviews as evidence that an organization is active and does what it says, especially when reviews mention specific programs. They also need clear facts on your website and consistent listings, and no one can guarantee placement in an AI answer.
How many Google reviews does a nonprofit need?
There's no set number. A steady flow of recent, specific reviews matters more than one big burst. Aim to ask after every event, adoption and volunteer orientation so new reviews keep arriving month after month.